Theses 09 / 20 AGAINST published 05 Apr 2026 · updated 06 Sept 2026 · v30

Microsoft Has Lost the Plot

Microsoft's strategic position is deteriorating despite surface-level AI investment. They lack internal frontier models and depend on entity/openai, which is itself strategically unfocused — the Forbes "OpenAI Graveyard" documents deals and products that never materialised, while Anthropic's focus on a smaller number of things continues to pay off. Copilot has "Product Market Failure" (John's phrase). The entity/microsoft integration of Anthropic into Copilot Cowork confirms

+25.3pp
Basket vs S&P 500since published — the verdict number
Basket absolute+40.0% · 1 instrument
S&P 500 same period+14.7%
Call directionBearish ↓

A bearish call is scored on performance relative to the market, not the raw tape.

InstrumentPriceTodaySince publishedvs SPY90d
MSFTMicrosoft 521.91 -1.6% +40.0% +25.3pp —
SPYS&P 500 — benchmark 755.72 -1.8% +14.7% — —
Basket: Single-name thesis

The research system PRO

  • Full analysis — the complete living document behind this call
  • Version history — watch the thesis evolve, v1 → v30, with change notes
  • Evidence archive — all 133 signals filed to this thesis
  • The knowledge graph — entities, concepts & comparisons behind the call
  • Your agent gets a key — full API access to the same system
Get NOOPS Pro
When we're wrong

3 theses are currently moving against us — Agents as Primary Users, +12.2% since published; Microsoft Has Lost the Plot, +40.0% since published; The SaaS Apocalypse, +42.0% since published. They stay on the board. We update priors on evidence, not on evidence we went looking for.